This post comes from Creative Carbon Scotland
Last week Creative Carbon Scotland met for the fourthÂ Green Teas(e) at GoMA for tea and biscuits and to build on the discussions had at the last meet, the aim of which was to identify some of the characteristics that might make up a sustainable Glasgow and cultural sector. Â Once more the group had an exciting gathering of folk from across the arts and sustainability organisations in Glasgow including artist Nic Green, Steve Taylor, Festival 2014 Sustainability Manager, Ailsa Nazir and Claire Ferguson from CCA, and Fiona Sinclair from NHS and the Art in the Gart Programme.
Four key characteristics identified previously were taken as the starting point:
- Making sustainability the cultural norm through strong leadership, influencing audiences and supply chains;
- Increasing the transparency of the trade-offs and complexity of decision making;
- Education playing a key role not only in increasing awareness but engaging people in a way that does not â€˜imposeâ€™ or â€˜withholdâ€™ the ability to live more sustainably;
- Supporting/creating more local, closed loop economies.
This time Creative Carbon Scotland wanted to find out from the group what these characteristics would look like in concrete terms.
To set the cogs in motion artist Ellie Harrison told the group about how she has come to embed environmental sustainability within her artistic practice, not just in terms of content but also her approach to making work. She spoke about the conflict she experienced as being a maker of â€˜stuffâ€™ and sometimes â€˜pointless objectsâ€™ and her desire to live more sustainably, but also the useful skills that artists have including the â€˜ability to innovate and changeâ€™ and â€˜arrogance and self-beliefâ€™. Much of her work now focuses on political activism and campaigning including projects such as â€˜Bring Back British Railâ€™ which lobbies for public ownership and availability of cheap public transport.
The group also heard from Katie Bruce, Producer Curator at GoMA, about a new â€˜Associate Artistâ€™ project starting at GoMA this year in which an artist will be selected to work with gallery staff to challenge existing structures and explore new ways of working with the ambition of building stronger internal capacity for collaborative, participatory working practice, which make a difference to GoMAâ€™s carbon footprint.
This model of the artist as researcher and catalyst of change within an organisation can be seen as a micro-level equivalent to our ambition of Green Teas(e) through which we aim to create new ways of working within the cultural sector which in turn influence a more sustainable Glasgow (and vice versa).
Looking backwards from 2020, the group asked what the above characteristics might look like in a sustainable Glasgow. We split off into groups and came up with the following points. (Note that the language and concepts and quite technical, complicated and sometimes difficult but that was the nature of the discussion.)
Some crosscutting themes which linked all of the characteristics were identified, including:
- Nurturing non-material values and moving towards non-financial ways of measuring things
- Encouraging agency (peopleâ€™s capacity to take action and achieve things) and a shift away from dominant models
- Creating a Glasgow in which space exists in everyoneâ€™s lives to develop their own agency
1.Â Making sustainability the cultural norm through strong leadership, influencing audiences and supply chains
The concept of â€˜strong leadershipâ€™ was challenged here as adhering to dominant models which typically favour more â€˜masculine characteristicsâ€™. However, it was also agreed that leadership is important in creating space for and empowering others to develop their own agency. Fiona Sinclair from Art in the Gart and NHSGGC Mental Health North Western spoke about the disempowerment of individuals that can exist in large organisations such as the NHS and the need to create spaciousness, whether in terms of staff time or the ability to be critical and reflective,Â which might begin to instil a great â€˜consciousnessâ€™ of sustainability. There was also concern around the term â€˜normâ€™ in relation to cultural diversity in which different forms of and approaches to achieving a sustainable city was favoured.
2.Â Increasing the transparency of the trade-offs and complexity of decision making
Here it was discussed that the scale at which decisions are made needs to be appropriate to the scale of the issue, i.e. creating local and city-wide subsidiarity (the devolution to the lowest appropriate level of decision making) which the public have trust in through a transparency in the decision making process and why decisions have been made. This also links to the agency and empowerment at grassroots level up.
3. Education playing a key role not only in increasing awareness but engaging people in a way that does not â€˜imposeâ€™ or â€˜withholdâ€™ the ability to live more sustainably
The group talked about creating a â€˜new departmentâ€™ within government, local authorities and other organisations which specifically deals with education and sustainability. In a broader sense, this concept of the â€˜new departmentâ€™, whether thatâ€™s new ways of working or new space given to embedding environmental sustainability into everyoneâ€™s consciousness, could provide a model for creating a more sustainable society. This links to Elinor Ostrumâ€™s polycentric approach to environmental protection â€œwhere key management decisions should be made as close to the scene of events and the actors involved as possibleâ€ (relating back to subsidiarity and agency again). The same could be applied to education and decision-making, where diverse nodes of activity are enabled to grow across different areas of society and eventually link up with one another.
4.Â Supporting and creating more local, closed loop economies
The need to create local currencies which feed into more local economies as well as developing a cradle to cradle system of resource use were agreed on as important components of a closed loop economy. In order to reuse and recycle our resources we would also need to develop a varied skill set which enables us to re-make, adapt and mend the stuff around us, thus combating the obsolescence currently built into many of the things we own.
These quite technical descriptions arenâ€™t particularly art-focused and so the job for the next Green Teas(e) is to think about how the arts help achieve these various characteristics of a sustainable city.
List of Attendees
Penny Anderson â€“ Writer/artist
Michelle Emery Barker â€“ Wasps
Kathryn Beckett â€“ GSofA
Katie Bruce, GoMA
Rachel Duckhouse â€“ Artist
Claire Ferguson â€“ CCA
Nicola Godsal â€“ Community & Volunteer Development Officer at NVA
Nic Green â€“ Artist
Ellie Harrison â€“ Artist
Andy MacAvoy â€“ Edo Architecture
Ailsa Nazir â€“ CCA
Eilidh Sinclair â€“ GsofA
Fiona Sinclair â€“ NHSGGC northwest sector
Elaine Slaven â€“ Carbon Management Awareness Officer, Glasgow Life
Ben Spencer â€“ Velocity
Steve Taylor â€“ Festival 2014 Sustainability Manager
Image: Ellie Harrison, Early Warning Signs,Â http://www.ellieharrison.com/
– Gemma Lawrence, 29.01.14
The post Blog: Green Teas(e) Reflections appeared first on Creative Carbon Scotland.
Creative Carbon Scotland is a partnership of arts organisations working to put culture at the heart of a sustainable Scotland. We believe cultural and creative organisations have a significant influencing power to help shape a sustainable Scotland for the 21st century.
In 2011 we worked with partners Festivals Edinburgh, the Federation of Scottish Threatre and Scottish Contemporary Art Network to support over thirty arts organisations to operate more sustainably.
We are now building on these achievements and working with over 70 cultural organisations across Scotland in various key areas including carbon management, behavioural change and advocacy for sustainable practice in the arts.
Our work with cultural organisations is the first step towards a wider change. Cultural organisations can influence public behaviour and attitudes about climate change through:
Changing their own behaviour;
Communicating with their audiences;
Engaging the publicâ€™s emotions, values and ideas.
Go to Creative Carbon Scotland
Powered by WPeMatico